On July 28, 1755 the order of
(Acadian) exile was signed. On September 5, 1755, a tragic day in Acadian
history, 418 Acadian men and teenage boys at Grand Pré were ensnared
and told the following by Col. John Winslow:
"I have received from
his Excellency Governor Lawrence, the King's Commission which I have in
my hand and by whose orders you are convened together to manifest to you
his Majesty's final resolution to the French inhabitants of this his Province
of Nova Scotia who for almost half a century have had more indulgence granted
them, than any of his subjects in any part of his Dominions... That your
lands and tenements, cattle of all kinds and livestock of all sorts are
forfeited to the Crown with all other your effects saving your money and
household goods and you yourselves to be removed from this his province."
Simply because the Acadian delegates
refused to sign another oath of allegiance that would have stripped them
of their rights, the British Crown made the decision to deport them and
to confiscate their belongings. The Acadians had done no wrong. With the
possible exception of a few men following the French Abbé Le Loutre,
they had not given any sign of insurrection. All they had done was continue
to speak French, practice Catholism and turn lands no one else wanted into
the envy of the British Empire.
I spite of any criticism one may
have about the present-day Petition for an apology - all those involved
are long dead, another example of political correctness run amok, what difference
does it make, etc. - there are a few incontrovertible facts that make it
necessary: on July 28, 1755 France and England were at peace. Furthermore,
the Acadians, by virtue of the Treaty of Utrecht of 1713, were British,
not French, subjects. They had already pledge allegiance to the British
Crown with certain stipulations, such as not being required to take up arms
against the French. Under the rule of law, these are paramount distinctions.
The Grand Dérangement
set into motion a series of events that have repercussions to this day.
There are economists who opine that Nova Scotia's economy was devasted for
generations after the expulsion of the farmers who knew how to work the
land, and indeed the ill effects are still felt today, if to a lesser degree.
The main benefit of the Royal
Proclamation is to remind people that this sort of atrocity can happen at
any time to anyone. It is submitted that because Beausoleil (Broussard)
led the Acadian resistance, the Royal Proclamation grants to him, as representative
of the Acadian people, a posthumous redemption. It reads:
Whereas the Acadian people,
through the vitality of their community, have made a remarkable contribution
to Canadian society for almost 400 years;...
Whereas on July 28, 1755 the
Crown, in the course of administering the affairs of the British colony
of Nova Scotia made the decision to deport the Acadian people;...
And whereas by Order in Council
P.C. 2003 1967 of December 6, 2003 the Governor in Council has directed
that a proclamation do issue designating July 28 of every year, as A Day
of Commemoration of the Great Upheaval, commencing on July 28, 2005;...
Now know you that we, by and
with the advice of Our Privy Council for Canada, do by this Our Proclamation,
effective on September 5, 2004 designate July 28 of every year as A Day
of Commemoration of the Great Upheaval commencing on July 28, 2005."
In 1990, the Petition was commenced
to officially declare an end of the Acadian exile because it was carried
out in violation of British and international law; therefore the British
government and Crown had a moral obligation to acknowledge that a wrong
occurred: the Acadians should not have been exiled as criminals. Richard
Baudoin penned the first article written about the Petition in the Times
of Acadiana ("Time to End the Exile," Volume 10, Number 23,
February 14, 1990, pages 8-11), it begins as follows:
"The exile begins never
to end... Warren Perrin is haunted by this line from Longfellow's poem Evangeline.
It conveys the tragedy of the Acadian people, banished from their ancestral
lands by a violent and cruel governor bent on genocide. It describes an
injustice that has never been acknowledged, a crime never punished, a wrong
never righted. Perrin, an Acadian by origin (90% Broussard on his paternal
and maternal sides) and an attorney by profession, is seeking to close the
book on this gross violation of basic human rights. He has drafted a lawsuit
that sets out the grievances of the Acadian people and asks for compensation
from the government of Great Britain, in whose name the deed was carried
out 235 years ago.
Perrin does not seek monetary
damages, either for the lands that were seized from his ancestors in Acadie
nor for the suffering they endured during their odyssey from Nova Scotia
to South Louisiana. Rather he wants the English to admit that 'Le Grand
Dérangement ('the clearest case of genocide you can find') was carried
out in violation of English and international law of the time. And he wants
the British government to erect a monument ---une symbole physique--- which
would represent the end of the exile.
Five years later, Bernard Chaillot
wrote an article for The Daily Iberian, "Erath Man Seeks Formal
Apology for Acadian Exile," July 3, 1995:
Warren Perrin said he is on
a mission to help right a grievous wrong--- the genocide and scattering
of an oppressed minority group in Eastern Canada more than 200 years ago.
An attorney, founder of an Acadian Museum here (in Erath, LA), and
president of the Council for the Development of French in Louisiana, Perrin
said he is seeking a formal apology from the British government for the
expulsion of Acadians from Nova Scotia in the mid-eighteenth century. Perrin
also said the deportation order, which exiled French Acadian settlers from
their homes and separated families and forced many to undertake risky sea
voyages to start new lives in Louisiana and elsewhere, never annulled.
This is how the Times of Acadiana
("Good - All Apologies," Vol. 24, No. 13, December 17, 2003) reported
the signing of the Royal Proclamation:
Understatement: Warren
Perrin is extremely delighted. At 2 p.m. Wednesday, December 9, 2003 Governor
Adrienne Clarkson, the Canadian head of state and the Queen of England's
representative in Canada, signed a royal proclamation (se below) that not
only acknowledged the expulsion of some 15,000 Acadians from Canada but
recognized the wrongs it caused. The proclamation -signed in Ottawa- also
designated July 28 as an official day to commemorate the Acadians and the
expulsion. Perrin started the movement for recognition and apology in 1990
by sending a letter to Queen Elizabeth ll and her current prime minister.
Perrin, who even declined offers of money for endowed scholarships to quiet
his actions, credits the non-confrontational and non-financial nature of
the request for its success. Whether or not talk of the queen reading the
proclamation at Grand Pré, National Historic Site in Nova Scotia,
during a royal visit slotted for 2005 is true [it
didn't happen] doesn't seem to matter to Perrin. We are never going to
forget it, but it's closure. The queen is finally saying what happened to
you was wrong and it was in my name. She doesn't say I am terribly sorry,
but there are many other ways to apologize.
Therefore, instead of a proposed
monument acknowledging the responsibility of the British Crown in the events
of 1755 as had originally been requested, there is now a national holiday.
Instead of the many, but limited, number of visitors to a commemorative
site learning about this tragedy, now tens of millions of people will learn
about it, thus adding to the hopes of all people that such a thing never
happens again.
Elizabeth the Second, by the
Grace of God of the United Kingdom, Canada and Her other Realms and Territories
QUEEN, Head of the Commonwealth, Defender of the Faith.
To All to Whom these Presents
shall come of whom the same may in any way concern,
Greeting: A Proclamation
Whereas the Acadian people,
through the vitality of their community, have made a remarkable contribution
in Canadian society for almost 400 years;
Whereas on July 28, 1755 the
Crown in the course administering the affairs of the British colony of Nova
Scotia, made the decision to deport the Acadian people;
Whereas the deportation of
the Acadian people, commonly known as the Great Upheaval, continued until
1763 and had tragic consequences, including the death of many thousands
of Acadians - from disease in shipwrecks, in their places of refuge and
in prison camps in Nova Scotia and England as well as in the British colonies
in America;
Whereas we acknowledge these
historical facts and the trials and suffering experienced by the Acadian
people during the Great Upheaval;
Whereas we hope that the Acadian
people can turn the page on this dark chapter of their history;
Whereas Canada is no longer
a British colony but a sovereign state, by and under the Constitution of
Canada;
Whereas when Canada became
a sovereign state, with regard to Canada, the Crown in right of Canada and
the provinces succeeded to the powers and prerogatives of the Crown in right
of the United Kingdom;
Whereas We, in Our role as
Queen of Canada exercise the executive power by and under the Constitution
of Canada;
Whereas this Our present Present
Proclamation does not, under any circumstances, constitute a recognition
of legal of financial responsibility by the Crown in right of Canada and
of the provinces and is not, under any circumstances, a recognition of,
and does not have any effect upon any right or obligation of any person
or group of persons;
And whereas, by Order in Council
P.C. 2003-1967 of December 6, 2003 the Governor in Council has directed
that a proclamation to issue designating July 28 of every year as "A
Day of Commemoration of the Great Upheaval", commencing on July 28,
2005;
Now know you that we, by and
with the advice of Our Privy Council for Canada, do by this Our Proclamation,
effective on September 5th, 2004 designate July 28 of every year as "A
Day of Commemoration of the Great Upheaval", commencing on July 28,
2005.
Of all which Our Loving Subjects
and all others whom these Presents may concern are hereby required to take
notice and to govern themselves accordingly.
In testimony whereas, We have
caused this Our Proclamation to be published and the Great Seal of Canada
to be hereunto affixed.
Witness:
Our Right Trusty and Well-beloved
Adrienne Clarkson, Chancellor and Principal Companion of Our Order of Canada,
Chancellor and Commander of Our Order of Military Merit, Chancellor and
Commander of Our Order of Merit of the Police Forces, Governor General and
Commander-in-Chief Canada.
At Our Government House, in
Our City of Ottawa, this ninth day of December in the year of Our Lord two
thousand and three and in the fifty-second year of Our Reign.